
- Your hourly rate is what it costs to keep the shop open each month, plus the profit you want, divided by the hours you actually bill.
- The trap is the divisor. A tech who spends eight hours in the shop rarely bills eight, and if you run the numbers on hours present instead of hours billed, the rate comes out too low and you lose money without noticing.
- Diagnostics and electrical work can carry their own rate.
- Redo the math at least twice a year, and sooner if inflation where you work is eating into your costs from one quarter to the next.
Say your shop charges a round hourly figure that somebody picked three years ago, when the rent was different and there was one fewer tech on the floor. Is that rate still enough? If you can't answer with the numbers in front of you, it probably isn't.
Labor is the one thing a shop sells that can't be kept for another day, because a part you don't fit today goes on next week, while an hour a tech spends standing around is gone for good and nobody gives it back. That's why the price of that hour has to cover everything it costs to keep the doors open. Not just wages.
The formula, no frills
Calculating a shop labor rate comes down to one division. The minimum hourly rate is the shop's total monthly cost divided by the billable hours in the month, and if you add the pre-tax profit you want on top of the cost, you have your target rate. Sounds obvious. What changes the result is what you put on each side of the division, and that's where almost everyone goes wrong by being optimistic, counting fewer costs than they really have and more hours than they really sell.
On top, what it costs to open each month
Take a normal month (not December, and not the month you replaced a lift) and add up everything that goes out of the shop even if not a single car comes in.
- Wages for all staff, with whatever payroll taxes and benefits the shop pays in your country, because the service advisor and whoever keeps the books cost money too even if they never turn a wrench all day.
- Rent and insurance.
- Utilities, which are no small thing in a shop running a compressor and several lifts.
- Equipment depreciation, worked out by spreading what each machine cost over the months of useful life you expect from it, so a lift meant to last ten years “costs” its price divided by 120 every month even once it's paid off.
- Small tools and consumables that nobody bills separately.
- Subscriptions, from your shop software to the licenses on your diagnostic equipment.
- Your accountant and your advertising.
- Your own wage if you're the owner and you work in the shop. It's the most expensive thing to forget. Leave it out and the numbers look fine while you work for free.
Underneath, the hours you actually bill
This is where most shops get it wrong. A tech who spends 44 hours a week in the shop doesn't sell 44 hours, because time goes on waiting for a part that hasn't shown up, shuffling cars around the lot, chasing a fault that never gets billed in full or redoing a job that came back. The ratio between hours on site and hours that end up billed on a work order is usually called utilization, and in a small shop it tends to sit well below what the owner imagines.
If you don't have the figure, measure it for two or three weeks. Log each tech's hours on site and compare them with the hours billed on that same period's work orders, without rounding in your favor. The ratio you get is your real percentage. Use that one.
A full example, step by step
The numbers below are made up and in a generic currency, so swap each figure for your own and keep the order of the calculations, which is the part that actually matters.
| Item | Example value |
|---|---|
| Monthly shop cost (everything on the list above) | 36,000 |
| Techs working on cars | 3 |
| Hours on site per tech per month | 176 (44 h × 4 weeks) |
| Measured utilization (hours billed ÷ hours on site) | 70% |
| Billable hours per month | 3 × 176 × 0.70 ≈ 370 |
| Cost of each billable hour | 36,000 ÷ 370 ≈ 97 |
| Target profit (15% on cost) | 5,400 |
| Target hourly rate | (36,000 + 5,400) ÷ 370 ≈ 112 |
Now see what happens if the owner runs the numbers on the 528 hours on site instead of the real 370. The cost comes out at about 68 an hour. Charge 87 believing that's 28% over cost and the shop is really losing about 10 on every hour it sells, so the busier the month, the more money walks out the door. Same shop, same people. Only the divisor changed.
Book time or actual time
Once the rate is set, you still need to know how many hours to multiply it by on each estimate, and there are two schools of thought. With actual time you charge for however long the tech took, which is easy to explain to the customer but punishes an efficient shop, because the fast tech ends up billing less than the slow one for the same job. With flat-rate or book time, taken from the labor guides that manufacturers and repair databases publish, you charge what the job should take. If your tech finishes sooner, the difference is yours.
Most shops end up somewhere in between. Book time for repetitive jobs like brakes or timing belts, and actual time for diagnostics and electrical faults, where nobody knows how long it'll take until they start measuring. What matters is that the customer knows in advance which of the two you're charging.
One rate or several?
Charging the same for fitting brake pads as for tracking down an intermittent fault on the CAN bus makes little sense, because diagnostics needs expensive equipment with licenses that renew every year and a better-trained tech, someone you don't want tied up on simple jobs. Plenty of shops separate general repair from electrical diagnostics, and some add a third rate for body and paint. If you split them, run the calculation again for each area.
And charge for diagnosis. A free diagnosis is an hour of your best tech's time that leaves without an invoice, and it also attracts the customer who only wants to know what's wrong so they can get it fixed somewhere else, sometimes with your printout in their hand. If you'd rather deduct it from the repair when the customer goes ahead, put that in writing once.
When to run the numbers again
Every six months at the very least. Where inflation is high, redo it whenever a big cost moves noticeably, even mid-quarter, and also when you hire someone, when you buy equipment that shifts your depreciation or when utilization rises or falls for several weeks in a row. A rate nobody reviews falls behind on its own.
How Promec handles it
In Promec you set up your labor rates and the AI uses them when it prepares each estimate, so nobody has to remember what an hour of diagnostics costs or apply an old price by eye. The mechanic productivity report shows the hours billed by each tech and the revenue each one brings in per hour, which is exactly the figure you need for the divisor in the formula. What it won't do is choose the rate for you. That depends on your numbers. The next step, pricing jobs with that rate, is covered in the guide to auto repair estimates.
Tell us how your shop works and we'll show you where to find each figure, with your own rates and your own techs.
Get in touch →Frequently asked questions
How much should a shop charge per hour for labor?
It varies a lot by country and by type of shop, so a general figure won't help you much. The only one that matters is the one that comes out of your costs and your billable hours. Look at what shops in your area charge to see whether you're out of line with the market, but not to set your rate, because you don't know their costs or their utilization.
Do I include parts in the hourly calculation?
No. Parts are priced separately with their own margin, and if you mix them into the hourly rate you'll never know whether you make money on labor or only on selling parts.
What if my rate comes out well above the competition?
Check utilization first. Going from 60 to 75% cuts the cost of each hour by 20% without touching a single expense. Then look at which costs can be trimmed, and if it still doesn't add up, compete on specialty or speed rather than on price, which is a war usually won by whoever has the lowest overheads.
Is it better to charge by the hour or a fixed price per job?
Customers find a fixed price per job easier to accept. Behind the scenes, that price should come from book hours times your rate plus parts, so it stays anchored to the calculation and not to a hunch.